THIS IS 100% FICTIONAL AND PURELY FOR FUN. DONATE TO NIFTY SO WE CAN KEEP THE FUN GOING. ENJOY!!!
WARNING...Some of these matchup chapters may be extremely short due to me not having as much time to write and wanting to progress the story further.
Ch. 9b- Cj vs Zach
Literally no one who knew him was expecting to see Cj Koegal of all people to come running off the bus. Sure he was smoking hot with a killer smile, a lean ripped body, and a perfectly high sitting round bubble butt that was highlighted by a slim waist; but far as everyone knew Cj was a "good Christian man" who didnt even look at guys. Even Bananas thought of the time he asked Kenny about him and when he approached him back on Fresh Meat II he had to play it off like a joke to avoid completely disgusting the rookie so the fact he was sporting a cheek to cheek grin as he stood in front of them was even more puzzling. Zach was hoping to never see Cj again after he nearly beat him in what should've been an easy win for him. He was the first guy to reveal a crack in his armor and show that the only thing carrying Zach was his size. Everything about Cj was stirring up all of his insecurities and something clicked in him; as much as he wanted to get fucked right now, he couldn't let Cj be the one to do it. He almost beat him once and if he loses then it'll only make his first win look like a fluke, he NEEDED to win this. Cj was there to finally stop playing with toys and teasing strangers whenever he got the chance and get fucked. He used to be scared to take that step but once he got the offer to come here the money gave him the perfect excuse to throw caution to the wind and just do it. Best part about it was getting fucked by one of the Challenge studs he has been imagining since he started playing with his asshole. When he found out he was gonna be going against Zach, he was excited. Sure he was a complete bottom but he had the perfect sized dick for a virgin hole and all Cj needed to do was lose...
Diego- Cj, how does it feel to see Zach again? Cj- Well he beat me fair and square in a Hallbrawl but this is a game for real kem so I hope hes got what it takes to put up a fight. Diego- And Zach, any words for Cj? Zach- Nope. Let's get this started.
Zach was first up with oil and he tried to rush through it but of course he found himself slowly caressing the soft bulges of muscle along Cjs arms and his impeccable chest, the washboard abs appeared to pop even more as each one was bathed in oil. When he turned around Zach did the same to his back, basically massaging the mans back until he got down on his knees and was nearly face level with the perfectly round bubble butt that was covered in the finest layer of peach fuzz and framed perfectly by the gold jockstrap he was wearing that appeared to get lost beneath the curves of his ass cheeks practically calling out to Zach. Cj smiled to himself as he revelled in the way Zach was worshipping his body. It was his secret weapon that no man could resist and he was determined to push any man to their limits at the drop of a dime. Even now he made sure to flex his muscles beneath Zachs touch and stand in a way that reflected the light off his body in just the right way to mesmerize his target. Right now with Zach practically staring at his ass he knew that all his tricks were working his magic. As he oiled up the supple mounds of flesh Zach couldn't help but feel envious of the specimen in front of him. Still he couldn't let that distract him from the fact that he NEEDED to win. Once Zach finished with his legs it was time to switch places and Cj could really start having some fun. Taking a page out of Wes' book Cj drizzled the oil over his arms but opted to tuck the bottle of oil into his crotch and use both hands to slowly massage the massive beefcake in front of him. Taking his teasing a step further he made sure to stand as close as he could to him and softly add fuel to the fire of desire inside him. Zach trembled as he felt his breath against his neck as the seductive tone of his voice felt like velvet inside his ear...
Cj- You know I've always thought your arms were huge but in my hands they're fucking massive. And that's not even the best part, the real kicker is how damn smooth your skin is and I can only imagine what it's like to be wrapped up in them while you hold me against these huge pecs of yours...
He started to move on to oiling up his torso...
Cj- ...while your abs dig into my lower back and your little funsized dick gets absolutely devoured by my ass.
Zach was puzzled because the goal here was the beat and fuck your opponent but it sounded like Cj wanted to get fucked instead. As he started on his back Zach couldn't even hear the words being spoken directly into his ear as he pondered the possibility of actually get fuck Cj. Maybe it was exactly what he needed to feel like the man again. Once Cj finished it was Zach turn and he wasted no time lathering the lean frame of his opponent, making it quick as possible to avoid getting too horny. He couldn't help himself once he got to his amazing ass with cheeks with so plump and round yet sculpted to perfection and tight as hell as the cheeks came together to complete hide virgin strawberry starfish between them as they jutted out towards his face practically beckoning him to come closer. Never in his life has Zach seen a more perfect ass and it was in that moment that he knew he had to have it, he HAD to win. With both men glistening head to toe in body oil they headed into the ring and into their corners then waited for the whistle. Zach was trying to figure out his best strategy. He knew Cj would be hard to pin down and probably a lot quicker than him so he was gonna have to think fast and act faster. CJ on the other hand was grinning ear to ear as he had the perfect plan to make sure he was the real winner here. The bell for the first round rang and before Zach could move, Cj surprised everyone by immediately dropping his jockstrap revealing his rock hard 7in dick which stood out against hiscompletely clean shaved pelvis. Zach was confused by his tactic but he wasnt gonna let him throw him off his guard. Cj just smirked at him before tossing his jock across the ring at Zach, hitting him right in the face with it as Zach just threw it off to the side and collected his buttplug for round two...
Zach- Well that was stupid. Cj- Figured you could used the help.
The bell rang for round two and Zach slowly made his way over to Cj while Cj just patiently waited to make his move. Once he was within arms reach, Cj surprised everyone again by simply turning around and presenting his ass to Zach with a smile on his face. Zach was puzzled and wondered if Cj was planning to pull a quick one but it didnt stop him for long. Cjs anticipation was finally over once he felt Zach take one more step closer and the familiar sensation of his hole being penetrated by a buttplug filled him with pleasure. Just like that, the match was over and Zach had won (or so he thought)....
Diego- Congratulations Zach. You just doubled your bank account and now you get to fuck your rival.
No time was wasted as Zach just pulled Cj down on his knees right in his corner of the ring, making him arch his back as he lined himself up with the well trained but still technically virgin hole. Zach removed the plug and put it in his own ass and Cj felt the small dick lined up with his entrance. He decided to shock everyone again by rocking back and taking all four hard inches of dick into his ass with a moan that oozed with an insatiable and inpatient appetite that Zach was all too familiar with. The moaning was just the first thing he noticed, the second being how tight yet well trained his hole was. Zach could feel Cj making his already tight ass even tighter as his anal ring clamped down before swallowing up his dick with each thrust. Even as a top Zach had no control or influence or any kind, once again he was reduced to a piece of meat that existed just to be used for the pleasure of another man just like his buddy Tony. He couldn't even enjoy the insanely tight velvet canal massaging his dick, or the round peach fuzz mounds of flesh bouncing off his pelvis, or the deep moans Cj was letting out with each thrust, all because he wished it was him with a dick inside him. Even worse, the buttplug inside him wasnt doing anything at all. While Cj was on cloud nine and eyeballing Nam the whole time, Zach was trying his best to get this over with but topping wasnt doing anything for him. He tried to imagine Rogan slutting him out on night one, then Joss joining in on night two and the train they ran on his ass all night. With Rogan and Joss being so hot for each other, they'd end every round on Zachs ass in a full makeout session that got them horned up and tag teaming his ass once again. He could almost feel the two cocks inside him as he thought more about it. As Cj continued throwing his ass back on his dick, Zach was starting to feel that tug in his balls but strangely it felt like it was going to his ass. Cj was starting to speed up and his moans were increasing while Zach felt the walls off his hole convulsing more and more which was sending shockwaves to his prostate making him moan out even louder in his signature whiney bottom bitch high pitched voice. Everyone except the judges were confused as both men came together with Cj cumming right on the mat and Zach seemingly cumming in his ass but Zach was hunched over Cj with his cheeks flexing around the plug in his ass that was letting out small gushes of light pinkish cum. Zach was confused as to why he felt like he just came out of his ass....
Zach- I need a medic. Theres something wrong with my butt. Diego- You're fine Zach. Get out of the ring and we'll explain.
As they exited the ring Cj made sure to let know...
Cj- In case you still haven't figured it out, I lost being I wanted to get fucked for the first time by a real man. Unfortunately I only accomplished half of that but if you consider this a win I hope you enjoy knowing it only came because I gave it to you, in more ways than one in fact.
He smirked and ran off, shooting Nam a kiss while Zach approached the judges. Will walked up to Zach and spun him around then bent him over, presenting his ass to the rest of the group....
Diego- Now, some of you may have already noticed that you're starting to feel a little different. Well that's because after playing this game your bodies will be different. Paddy- Take Zach here, hes been opened up to his true bottom nature. Now his body is changing to match. Exhibit A...
With that Paddy slowly removed the buttplug, allowing everyone to see as his hole started to leak a cloudy light pink and blue cum like substance. On sight everybody except Bananas, Michael, Tony, and Kyle instantly got rock hard...
Will- True bottoms secrete their own lube and if any top sees, smells, or tastes it, theyll go into a horny frenzy. Diego- Now just because you have a hard dick right now doesn't mean anything. If you're versatile, your body is gonna let you know. Got it, good. Now let's get on with this thing. Next up to defend their bank account, "Daddy" Brad.
As Brad switched places with Zach, Caleb and Hunter went into full blown cheerleader mode...
Paddy- Ready to see who you're going against? Brad- Sure. Doesnt really matter who it is though, I'm winning this thing no matter what. Will- You sure about that? Brad- Positive. Diego- Then let's do it. Coming up next we got a battle of All Stars. Men that arent really Rivals but have had quite the infamous heated exchange in the past and the fans have been very vocal about what to see you two beasts do in the ring together. This Challenge legend had to be removed from a season for pounding in your face and now hes here to pound that ass....
....TBC IN 9C....IM BAAAAACK... HOPEFULLY THIS WASNT TOO SHORT...I DONT HAVE AS MUCH TIME TO WRITE BUT I DONT WANNA RUSH IT AND GIVE YOU ALL LAZY CHAPTERS EITHER SO IM TRYING TO FIND A BALANCE...ANYWAY HOPE YOU ENJOYED THIS AND KEEP THE GUESSES CUMMING FOR THE FUTURE MATCHUPS...TIL NEXT TIME